HI from the critique club!
i remember this image, i voted on it, gave it a 7. i thought it was a lovely idea. some things i might have done differently would be to level the camera with the bottom of the photo. i also would have either taken off the strap or perhaps curled it around the front so that it did not make the photo feel unbalanced. maybe dodging the background to create a brighter white rather than the yellowish color might have helped scores. i like how the red button on the old camera and the red on the new camera look, it shows a good comparison between the old and the new.
it seems stange to me that this photo did not do better, it fit the challenge well and was a great idea. |