I really like this one Andy. The crowded scene works for me - after all it's war, they are all struggling togeather. The processing works for me as well, makes it look a bit surreal which is reasonable given it's the civil war. NIce shot,
Looks a bit overprocessed, maybe too much Shadow/Highlight or similar. It is also a bit too crowded in the center, difficult to focus on any person individually, and most faces are partly hidden. You captured a good moment, but a different point of view (more from the front?) I think would have helped.
the processing would be great if there were fewer musicians... but now it just emphasizes the clutter of your subjects... a face behind a face behind a drumstick, etc. The grass looks *fantastic* though (fangrasstic?). Very close to being a great shot.