What a lovely shot!! Nothing like making good use of the "tools" you have. And, you know, everyone needs to get over the make-up....I imagine they were having a good time!!
I love the colours and the framing of this. The lighting is so soft and warm. This is one of those photos where you can see the loving care the photographer put into it, making sure everything was just right, but not to the point that it kills the feeling of life and spontaneity in it. 10 - lisae
This is a great shot the colors are beautifull. In my opinion the only thing keeping it from a 10 is the cropping, show head of both girls, or 1/3 (head and upper torso, but the way you have them posed I would sugust a full shot. Still ine of my top 10 picks.
I can't tell if I see twins or one girl reflected in something that works just like a mirror. I think it would have been better if you zoomed in on the girl(s),
I would have liked to have seen a difference between the 'model' and the 'reflection'. Unless I'm missing something, the twins are as identical as they can be. Something subtle that you don't notice at first glance but when you do makes you blink and say 'hang on, it can't be a mirror because...' would really make the picture stunning.
As it is, still one of the best and worthy of a 9.
This is really cool. I really thought the challenge was to shoot an actual reflection using a reflective surface, but I only subtract 1 for not meeting the challenge so ... 8 ~indigo997
If this doesn't win – I'll… well, I don't know what I'll do… This is just so totally superb I can't even begin to try and find fault. The idea, the effort, and those sublime (twins?) kids really make this one of the best pictures I have seen to date on any challenge. (100) If any one scores this less than 10, they should be banned from the site :o) Awesome… Good luck…
This is a creative idea, and it shows all the hard work that you put into it, specially for getting the twins to have the patience to pose for your picture. The mirror effect was accomplished 100%. Just look at the administrator's note on the picture, it is fantastic! I can imagine all the comments you're getting.
I absolutely adore this photo. Beautifully composed (in my eye), clever as all hell and MORE than meeting the challenge. Raised this to my personal "10" for this week.
OK, another update. I REALLY looked at it this time and I see it now. Great concept. It must have taken a lot of work to set this up and get it so near perfect. Great job.
Very original idea....or maybe not if you have identical twins... The composition could have been better, there is too much empty space to the right and not enough of the girl on the left.
Twins? Another nice trick. The wall is the give away. (also the left girl has a fold in her top at the shoulder, the right doesn't.) VERY nice color. 9 Swash
Twins? In fact do I recognize this very pair from one of the photos in my favs?Very creative interpretation. Would like it tilted just a hair to make the doorway straight. Still, great job. 8, just-married
I would have given this a higher mark if the DHILDREN didn't have make up on. They doesn't need makeup. They are beautiful enough without eyeshadow, mascara, lipstick and blush. I do not mean to insult the photographer; I just wanted to mention this. LIttle girls grow up too fast as it is!
I was wondering if we would see some twins. Very pretty models. Although this is not the kind of reflection I think most of us were going for, they are definitely reflecting.
Wow... great shot - I'm not sure how you pulled this off without the mirror? :) Technically a good photograph as well... you could have maybe cropped a hair tighter on the right? Great job! - 8 - JB
Amazing photo !!!! I had to look long and hard to see what this really is. Twins. The white area is beautiful...the detail is just awesome ! = 10 Shiiizzzam