I think this picture should have done better!!! It is very creative and original! I didn't vote on this challenge, but I would have given this at least an 8 or 9!
I was unable to find a reflection is this image. IMHO, as a butterfly photo, it would require more sharpness and focus. Cropping out the wings tip makes it incomplete. I would have left at least one complete wing, and the other could be cropped accordingly with the desired composition.
The entire photo has to be the reflection here, as I don't see any other reflections. I am not sure how this was done though, if the whole shot is the reflection. anyway, the angle is really nice and the framing/cropping are good. the focus and clarity are good, the details in the wings are great. good luck in the challenge. ~Hbunch7187~
Nice butterfly! Am I missing something here? What's reflecting? I like this shot very much, even if I think it's cropped too tightly. Today's score 6, convince me there is a reflection and I will raise it. Swashbuckler
Cool. A reflection that's organic rather than optical. Or is there a 'real' reflection in there as well that I've missed? I hope not. 8 for being inventive.
Is this a whole picture reflection? I think you would have done better to have included some way for the viewer to see this for a reflection rather than just a straight shot. Something outside the reflection could have helped tremendously.
But of course that's just my opinion... It's how YOU feel about the shot that counts :)
Nice picture...I'd prefer to see WHAT the butterfly is reflected in, but still nice. Could be clearer. A bit dark. Good luck in the challenge. Grayce aka Gracious
This is a wonderful shot, and I can see symmetry, and I can see beauty, it's technically superb - but I can't really see any reflection in the shot, I 'm really sorry, but I don't think it meets the challenge… (4)