I didnt vote in this challenge but I would have probably given this a 5. You did meet the challenge by presenting the voter with somethign that had curves. But IMO its just a straightforward picture of a vase/sculpture thing. There just isnt a whole lot of creativity to the presentation of the object. Its centered, the angle isnt overly interesting. It's more of a product shot style. Allowing some shadows on your backdrop may have been nice to show some depth or light play.
Its in focus, exposed well, no real technical issues that I can see. It just doesnt have any real wow impact that the DPC voters want. Hope that helps.
Tim |