Author Thread
Post actions
Almost got another brown...Message edited by author 2008-03-19 00:06:04.
Post actions
Originally posted by noraneko:
I like this photo, but it actually looks like tack-sharp sand to me. Will be interesting to know what it is. Will skip voting on it.
Post actions
Originally posted by raish:
... The border is ghastly, but deliberate...
Post actions
Originally posted by paynekj:
I really like the concept, but you got the border wrong - that green is not a good colour to use.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I would like this much more w/out the border - both the color and the solidity of it clash w/ the rest of the picture.
Post actions
I don't know what it is but I like it. :)
Post actions
Fairly well-defined noise and a more or less organised dark/light graduation. The border is ghastly, but deliberate. The blurry mess is in my own judgement, not knowing whether to vote 1 or 10. I ain't sayin.
Post actions
personally i think it is an interesting take on the challenge and in some ways fits more than people might originally think (although i think Messy Blur would apply more ;)), but i actually have a revulsion for the colour you chose for the border... and the shot is secondary to it because of the eye being drawn towards it. A more neutral colour or even white or black would suffice and highlight the photo which is what you are submitting to the challenge.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
scratches my head you have confused me now lol
Post actions
I like this photo, but it actually looks like tack-sharp sand to me. Will be interesting to know what it is. Will skip voting on it.
Post actions
I really like the concept, but you got the border wrong - that green is not a good colour to use.
Post actions
Not a compelling image in the slightest. The border does not help.
Post actions
Ribbon for sure, brown of course.
Post actions
thats actually a great idea! i hope evryone doesnt hate it, its kinda way different then everyone else lol. good luck!
Post actions
you left frontal lobe types,always shakin it up...kool,7
Post actions
blurry mess yes, but of what?
Post actions
Hmmm, not a very interesting shot, sorry .... doesn't keep my interest
Post actions
I'm unsure on this fits into the challenge (IMHO). I REALLY don't like the green border. The subject is unknown so it's hard to tell if there is any blur. I don't find it very chaotic/disorganized because it's the same pattern from top to bottom except for the lightness. Personally I also don't find it to be very interesting or have any wow factor. I rated this a 2, sorry.
Post actions
Post actions
Sorry... I don't get it. I commend you for being different and taking a risk but I don't get anything out of the image.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
