Initial=Very dramatic Composition=beautifully done Clarity (focus, details)=well done Exposure=very greyscale, but I like it... I wonder if a bit more contrast would further enhance the drama? Interesting or Emotive=This is excellent. A winner. I love the idea, the drama, the emotion... you have a great artistic eye. Nice work.
I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks autool!). I hope you find it helpful. Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0)
I love this photo, it's one of my 10s this week. I love the way the light chatches the girl's face in the reflection, and the mood the black and white and the background of pebbles give to her. I just wish it was a little bit clearer about what she's doing, it's hard to tell. But then the air of mystery would be gone. 10 (as I said) - lisae
A very interesting artistic photo. I'm not really drawn into this photo, but I'm not certain if it's the clutter of the reflection or that I don't see a connection between the two images, then again, does there have to be? Challenge well met, focus seems quite good. 7 Swash
Really nice shot. I think B & W was a great choice and the lighting is excellent. The model is quite pretty as well. It took a good eye and a lot of fore-thought on this one. DPz
real nice, great highlights on her cheek, looks like something by dave mckean, ever heard of him? you should look him up, did comic book covers, high art.
Very nice with a mood! Wish I knew what the reflectingh object was, but then I guess that would change the whole tone of the picture. The B & W is perfect. I love the light on her face. a 10 from me.
Technically correct , exposure6, focus7, saturation 6, contrast.6 too dark Good composition. 8 Tells a story or creates a mood 8 Impact to the viewer 8 Relevance to the Challenge 8 Overall 8 sulamk
I really like this shot. I like the b&w very much. It's just the tiniest bit on the dark side for me, but then again, that may be what gives it such a nice moody feel. Very cool idea. lhall-9
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
