Breadsticks! Simple is my 'thing' and I thought this was as simple as I could get. I'm wondering how many people will say 'this isn't bread'!? It's gonna happen...
Statistics
Place: 50 out of 167 Avg (all users): 5.5903 Avg (commenters): 6.0000 Avg (participants): 5.5333 Avg (non-participants): 5.6108 Views since voting: 912 Views during voting: 347 Votes: 227 Comments: 23 Favorites: 0
Well waddya know... :) Great to discover this one was yours. I thought the same as raish when I first saw this. Many print uses for it and you should seriously consider for stock. Way to go girly!
I'm sure some people love it, but for me, there's too much empty space. It's probably good if you are going to have an ad made out of it. I do love the clarity of the sticks and how well they contrast against the dark background.
more than a minimalist photo is a minimal photo. the subject on the left border and the black that fill the frame have a true charm. the only little problem that I can see is the very small reflection on the low side of the glass. 7
I like the lighting on the breadsticks, and I appreciate the experimental cropping, but... might been better cropped as a vertical. You still could've left lots of black on the left, just not as much as in this horizontal arrangement.
The straight lines, the simplicity of the shot is good. Love the negative space that you have gone for, it really makes stand out from the others. Wish the light bounce at the end of the glass was not there though. 9
A very daring use of negative space which doesn't quite work for me - there's no real interaction between the subject and the space and there's just so much space! I also wonder if this is a little oversharpened (the jaggies on the breadsticks are a little distracting). Good effort though.
If you could bring the breadsticks in a bit more so we can see them properly, then lose about half of the black, then (for me) this would be much stronger.
But I can certainly see where you were going with it.
I am a sucker for minimalism and just love empty space. But this one does not work for me, because your subject is too far to the edges of the pic. This would have worked so much better if you left some room around the subject instead of just to the right of it. Execution is fine though.