The person who voted ONE probably thought this was the panning challenge (the other exclusive ch. running).
This is a great and perfectly lit image!! One of the very few in the show that is able to tell a story.
I love the lighting on this. Maybe I just like it so much cos it reminds me of a painting in my grandparent's house. That's a good enough reason to give you a good score. (A well composed photo helps a lot too)