nice, Mr. Ansel Adams xcept you should have placed two thirds of the frame for the reflection on the water coz thats what the challenge is about-THE REFLECTION!
I like the clouds and in general i like the composition, although I feel there's a perceptible left-to-right downward slant which I can't stop looking at. 6 sjgleah
I would have said it would be better with more emphasis on the reflection rather than the sky itself. And the slight angle is distracting. I like the B&W though.
Great photo, but I see verical lines all through this shot, dark, light, dark, light, etc. I don't know what causes this, but it's distracting. (It's the worst in the clouds. I think I remember my camera doing this, but diagonally on RED flowers, why???) 8 Swash
Nice B&W but could have been improved by leveling the horizon. This looks like a classic rule of thirds landscape and while the reflection is clearly there - maybe putting the horizon on the top third and placing more emphasis on the reflection aspect - just a thought: 7 lamedos
This is a nice shot. Why b/w? I'm curious to see what the water looked like in full color. The picture does seem to have a pretty harsh tilt to the right also. - 6 - JB