Initial=a little funny Composition=unusual, although the sidewalk actually creates some interesting diagonals. Clarity (focus, details)=maybe was out of focus and then oversharpened? Exposure=Perhaps over exposed, or colors oversaturated Interesting or Emotive=only for a short while.
I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments. Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0) kpb
Pretty funny! The crop is a little too funky, though...think it would have been better to leave in the top of the hydrant and a little bit more of the dog (though I don't mind cropping him in half...but there's just not enough of him to really make this crop work). The grass and sidewalk overpower the pic, when you want the dog and hydrant to be the main focus. I like funky shots and odd crops, but this is a tad too *odd* to really work as well as it could...though it's purty darn close!
This is the corner of *your* world? A dog peeing?? Other than the subject of the photo not appealing to me, I'd have to say that the image seems a bit too sharp and harsh on the eyes, and maybe you could have taken the cyan down a bit within the image.