Author Thread
Post actions
didn't vote in tis challenge but if I had would have given it a 9 or 10 this so did not deserve the score it got... your take on the challenge was brilliant! well done even if your score doesn't reflect it... sadly another case of the general mass of DPC missing the boat :)
Post actions
Congratulations to you for your exceptional image that was
Post actions
I am amazed at how many people at dpc have never seen a banana. Just goes to show you the diversity of the membership.
Post actions
Originally posted by mark_u_U:
your bravery is unlikely to be rewarded. 7
Post actions
Claude Debussey said, "Music is the silence between the notes."
Post actions
Way underrated, but you can be proud of this shot and of having had the nerves to enter it!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Could have been a green banana....hard to tell with the desaturation.
Post actions
I guess you could call this loss of yellow.
Post actions
It's an OK picture, just not very inspiring to me
Post actions
Post actions
I get the banana IS yellow but B+W in a color challenge???
Post actions
Dude, this photo is black and white! No really i get it, but is the fact that i know its yellow the same as it being yellow? No it is the same as taking a picture of a banana in a lightness room, if there is no light there is no color. At the same time this photo made me think, (far to much in fact) that this photo is though provoking so what do i rate it? Well it good, well focused, and balanced but will the rest of the voters see this....
Post actions
the yellow??? were did it went?
Post actions
Post actions
your bravery is unlikely to be rewarded. 7
Post actions
interesting take on the challenge
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
nice desaturation. Clever but the shot is rather normal I think and relies too much on the desaturated effect rather than a great shot.
Post actions
An interesting take on the challenge! From a purely photographic point of view it might have been better to take a very ripe banana that has more black markingson the skin. 6.
Post actions
Where has all the yellow gone? I know my monitor settings are fine when I see yellow on all other pictures. :( This photo is way to desturated.
Post actions
good pose, but I don't see any yellow
Post actions
No yellow for the 'Yellow' challenge?
Post actions
Interesting take on yellow. I think it's BRILLIANT. :) I think you should get the OOBIE for this.
Post actions
i like the out of the box thinking.
Post actions
I wish I had the nerve to try black and white for a colour challenge
Post actions
I like the idea of showing yellow without color. good lighting and POV. might have been even better without the dust and the textured surface.
Post actions
it´s a banana...and the yellow? I don´t think it meets the challenge.
Post actions
Great! You defintly conveyed the color yellow withour even having the color in the photo. good comp and focus + nice idea and execution = 10 from me!
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
