Initial=Very interesting! Composition=well done Clarity (focus, details)=perfect DOF and clarity Exposure=done well Interesting or Emotive=I like what you have done by desaturating most of the other colors. Good job!
I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments. Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0) kpb
Okay, I'm undecided here. Write be back at cjmorgan59@aol.com. I'm tossed. Either it's a excellent images or it's a lousy one for this challenge. It seems like a stadium to me. Do you work there, or work there, or own it, or for some other reason spend a significant amount of time there? I'll vote more accurately once I know that.
very interesting use of selective desaturation :) I'm having trouble understanding the actual intent of the photo, but I like the image regardless... the repeating pattern here is excellent... - setzler
Nice trick. The sun on the farthest chair ain't so good, but still this very well done. On the personal side, it doesn't thrill me much. 7 Swash Oh yes, look at the legs of the chairs, don't they seem jaggy to you, too?
I really like this. The red and yellow color give it that extra punch. Very creative angle. The way the red chairs are not perfectly straight give it feel of "real". I'm sure you will do well on this challenge.
Wow! You are a very talented photoshop user and you have an excellent eye to see the opportunity within the rules and sieze it so beautifully. 9 crisa58