Geat composition, the space really adds to the effect.
To all intents and purposes this is a candle shot. The point deducted for the shine on the fingernail is added back for candle resemblence - clever :)
Interesting subject. Clearly photographed. Too much negative space for your eyes to wonder around . Would like to see a vertical crop so the subject would be the focus. "8"
I think this would have worked better breaking the laws a bit and placing the finger and flame in the centre. The halo around the top of the flame could have been cloned out for a cleaner image. I also feel the finger looks a little flat and either needed a bit of PS manipulation or better lighting to liven it up a bit. One of the better ideas I've seen on this challenge though, even if I've seen it before.