Author Thread
Post actions
Cool image and very well done.
Post actions
Excellent idea and a perfect shot!! Congratulations!!
Post actions
Brilliant shot. Thank you for posting the original. Very good idea executed perfectly.
Post actions
Great picture Andrew. Help me to understand how you did this without getting a reflection of the camera. I'm just getting started with photography and I need to learn all I can.
Post actions
Congrats on your Blue, Andrew! (and for your first ribbon!) Very original image, and wonderful post-processing made this one of my top pics! Happy New Year indeed :O)
Post actions
Post actions
great shot, well deserved ribbon. congrats on your first (of many I'm sure). Happy New Year ;-)
Post actions
Congratulations, and happy new year! I couldn't figure out how it was done either until I saw the original and explanation, and it looks relatively simple. It's a technique done many times but looks very original here. I don't know how you got the background so blurred at f9. The hand and ball must have been very close. Great job!
Post actions
CONGRATULATIONS!
Message edited by author 2007-12-31 13:55:31.
Post actions
One of the more original shots I have seen on here for a while. Good concept incredibly well executed.. Well done.
Post actions
Wonderful job! congrats on your first ribbon! feels good doesn't it!
Post actions
Such a great image!!! Congrats on your first ribbon!
Post actions
congratulations great picture
Post actions
Very clever shot ...congrats
Post actions
Wow. Great shot. Congrats on the ribbon.
Post actions
Very cool shot. Congrats!
Post actions
Congrats my friend!
Post actions
Really good job and a worthy winner. Congratulations.
Post actions
Congrats on your ribbon! Excellent shot!
Post actions
Congrats on your well deserved blue, exceptional image!
Post actions
well deserved blue, great shot!
Post actions
Congrats on the blue! It's a fantastic and creative shot!
Post actions
Congrats on the ribbon, a fantastic shot!
Post actions
Congratulations on your blue ribbon, Andrew. It's a stunning image, unusual and very creative.
Post actions
Grats on the ribbon - well deserved. And thank you for showing how you did it - I was totally perplexed by it and couldn't work out how that could be done in one shot! :) Happy New Year to you too
Post actions
Congrats on the blue - nice one for a first ribbon.
Post actions
Great image for a first Blue Ribbon...congratulations
Post actions
Congrats on you first ribbon, a blue one at that! Great Pic
Post actions
Outstanding shot. Congrats.
Post actions
Pretty amazing. Congrats on the blue!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
An amazing shot.. would love to see how it was done
Post actions
Post actions
This is wonderful, someday I hope to learn how to do this type of editing.
Post actions
Cool perspective indeed! Can't wait to read how you did this.
Post actions
an interesting solution, good idea! the reflection is nearly perfect.
Post actions
Amazing image. Intriguing and beautiful. I love the clarity of the ball, and the partial desat is perfect.
Post actions
Post actions
ineresting - I'd have liked more contrast in the bw part
Post actions
I don't like the shot... at all, but it meets the assignment 100%
Post actions
Great picture. The colors make this picture really pop.
Post actions
Very clever and beautiful composition.
Post actions
Nice! Cool perspective ..
Post actions
this is a very creative and one of the best idea in this challenge. Love the reflection-view! Very well done. Good luck!
Post actions
simply amazing. definitely a unique perspective. you got my 10!
Post actions
Very interesting concept, congrats!
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
not a big fan of selective desat. The shot itself is very good though.
Weather Forecast - Sunny but cloudy!
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
