I think kettle man was the first. Seriously, how does one come up with an idea like this anyway? Shake your money maker, baby.
I initially thought of someone being shocked to find that they bid on reflectoporn and when they got the item - the reflectoporn was gone! So I got my son to do the shocked look and when I processed it, he came out looking a little possessed. He may acually be, but I love him anyway.
Also, I think some haunted items have been sold on ebay as well. Here is one...
I thought this was hilarious when I saw it, but also winced, since we all know what happens to shots like these. :) Nicely original for this challenge.
I can't believe you linked to the haunted painting. I KNOW the painter! He's married to a colleague of mine, and I spent a pleasant evening in their loft when she hosted the office holiday party. Cool guy. He has a large version of it.
Haunted pot - hahahahaha!! This is so weird that I'm going to give it a good score. Also, I like your BW conversion - the high key, high contrast look.