Author Thread
Post actions
I'm very pleased this image finished so high, I was a bit worried it might not get the votes it deserved.
Post actions
Post actions
Nick - Awesome shot! Congrats on a top 10
Post actions
This is awfully well done. Here is a fine example of using good pp to good purpose.
Post actions
Oh, Wow! How beautiful. Excellent work. Congrats on top 10.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Love the stillness and the reflection.....AWESOME.....
Post actions
Very cool, nice tones, lovely sky, great job on the water there as well, a 9from me
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Beautiful shot. I love the tone, and the smoothness of the water. I really like the composition as well. Great work. 8
Post actions
Post actions
Wow, now that is calm water! Like a mirror. Beautiful tones in the image.
Post actions
Nice shot, love the tone and the highkey horizon. well done!
Post actions
Exquisite processing. I love the glassy water. The composition seems a bit heavy on the left, and the mast cuts the image straight down the middle.
Post actions
I love still water shots... the vignette works too.
Post actions
I always have liked reflections.
Post actions
i liked the image from first glance but as i study this i'm finding some faults, like the cut off mast, and some weird processing effecting the sky, I was thinking about dropping the score a bit, but after some thought i think i'll leave the score i first gave it (8). I think the first glance score should hold lots of weight after all that's all many photos get, just a glance.
Post actions
So Still, good use of the tones to tell the story...7
Post actions
A lot of potential, but I still feel the highlight areas are still overblown.
Post actions
wow, great smooth tones. Serene and beautiful.
Post actions
Very serene. I love the stillness.
Post actions
Fanstatic use of wide-angle, and very interesting post processing. The highlights are probably spiked on the right side of your histogram, but this is a very compelling image.
Post actions
Fantastic shot. Looks like a productive GTG! Much better than anything I was able to get. I love the reflections and the gradations of light. It has a wonderful softness to it, too. I'm guessing this is Nick's version.
Post actions
I'm impressed of ths clarity! Beautiful.
Post actions
wonderful mood. toning is spot on. - 9
Post actions
Very nice image. Great detail yet a soft feel to it. The color tone you chose works well with this.
Post actions
Beautiful duotome study, I like the crispness and serenity of the shot. A couple of wonderful little touches. The sharpness of the tree on the right and the fact that the mast of the boat looks like it is reflected to the left (which I appreciate is actually another boat) as well as in the excellent reflection)
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
