Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
is this from a civil war reinactment???
Post actions
Was it cloudy or foggy that day? Or is that gunsmoke?
Post actions
good idea. maybe a better composition and colors had helped, though
Post actions
The border is bit much.. Using more contrast would have helped..
Post actions
Unusual subject - it's a shame about the exposure - it's lost detail.
Post actions
I'm not sure why you would use such a thick border and make your photo smaller. Good idea but can't really tell where the battle is apart from a flag.
Post actions
Interesting effect with smoke/haze; it adds to the feel of the scene but obscures the "battle" in the distance. I might crop out about 10% at left and top.
Post actions
I like the haze and the way the subjects stick out from it. Frame is so-so for me 7
Post actions
This is a very beautiful picture. Wonderful subtle colors. Nice soft light. Composition good. In another category I think it could have been an 8 or 9.
Post actions
The composition is great but the photo is a bit washed out and the color of the border seems to make it worse.
Post actions
too cloudy / foggy, maybe you wanted that there for effect?
Post actions
Not at all a fan of the frame but I like the misty feel of the image itself.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
