Ayme, this shot is wonderful and deserved to place much higher, but you broke a 6, so that says something. :-) Still, I like this one alot. It was in my top 5.
Initial=great clouds and reflection Composition=water way leads the eye into the photo for depth Clarity (focus, details)=superb. I can see into the far distance. Exposure=well done Interesting or Emotive=interesting.. not incredibly emotive, but not necessary.
I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments. Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0) kpb
Truly gorgeous. The reflection is terrific; the colors are beautiful. If it were mine, I would crop out the light pole on the far left - it's the only teeny flaw in my opinion. 10, just-married
man, nice reflections. I would've concentrated on that -- the tree branch on the right is a bit distracting to a blaance image (symmetrical). 8 paganini