Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I really like this photo and find it interesting! I would think that it would have more impact if the knot was more to the left or the right of the photo. Then I think that it would have that wow thing. The rule of thirds for this one would work great to me.
Post actions
Great wood grain, nicely lit and sharp. I like the composition - it keeps the eye moving around the picture and into the cetral hole in the log.
Post actions
However you have acheived this effect the texture is just not of sufficient "strength" for my appreciation
Post actions
why would someone request a DQ on this? Focus seems a touch off but nice swirl to it.
Post actions
I can't begin to imagine why someone would challenge this photograph. 5
Post actions
Great composition and POV. Nice choice for the challenge.
Post actions
Nice picture, I like the colors. Maybe you could've added a border.
Post actions
Good shot. More sharpness would helped a lot
Post actions
Interesting pattern, little sense of surface texture. I think you've lost too much fine detail for that reeally to show through.
Post actions
Cool lines and texture. It almost appears to be a bit overshapened.
Post actions
Post actions
Seems to be a bit grainy, almost like the brightness/contrast was adjusted a bit too much, or perhaps slightly oversharpened.
Post actions
You did justice to this lovely remnant of a fine tree. Wonder if it is a bristlecone pine... Doesn't matter, it's a 10 in my book.
Post actions
Definitely texture. Would have been more interesting with a point of focus, such as a small clover or leaf and more interesting lighting.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
