Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
However, the pencil must be used or communicated as something other than a pencil in the photo.
Post actions
I like the composition here and the dof -- very neat. The dark spots in the top left corner are a bit distracting.
Post actions
Not sure how this meets the challenge
Post actions
nice contrast...nice work
Post actions
Lovely light and dof, but I'm looking at a pencil.
Post actions
Has potential but let down by inconsistencies in the white background and the fact that the pencil is OOF.
Post actions
Post actions
A picture of a pencil. Super. Wish I could give negative numbers.
Post actions
i love what this picture represents.
Post actions
Isn't this just a picture of a pencil?
Post actions
How is this being used as something other than a pencil?
Post actions
Like the placement of the shavings. Not sure what is in the upper left corner but it distracts from the image
Post actions
I don't see how this is being "represented as something other than a pencil."
Post actions
For me, your image doesn't communicate as something other than a pencil as stated in the challenge. I do like your composition though.
Post actions
However, the pencil must be used or communicated as something other than a pencil in the photo.
Post actions
it's a nice shot but as it's a pencil being nothing other than a pencil I don't really feel it meets the challenge. sorry.
Post actions
Doesn't meet the challenge.
Post actions
Post actions
the lighting is really uneven - the background with the smudges and grey texture make it seem a bit muddy, and the pencil seems to me to be acting like a pencil and not as something other than a pencil
Post actions
Isn't the pencil not supposed to be a pencil? The smudge on the top left is a little distracting to me. I like the pencil shavings though.
Post actions
still a pencil to me i'm afraid =(
Post actions
To me, this still shows a pencil as a pencil and I'm not sure but, I think the challenge called for a non-pencil usage in the shot. Nice shot though!
Post actions
Love your DOF...the clippings really add to your image. Nice lighting and tones. I like!! :)
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
