While this capture is reasonably accomplished and seductively rendered, as a photo, it is also short on -range-.
Both title and image relay the subject poignantly, yet the polished fringes of leather suggest an article of clothing and fashion rather than a material per se. The unfortunate and likely unintended effect is that someone viewing the image is reminded of catalog images, intended to sell a product.
If the article used here could have been more difficult to date and could be displayed more generically, this image would, IMHO, be an entirely different animal.
With a greater tonal range (both in the white and black areas), the photo would be transporting.
Despite my stated criteria, I consider it among the best in this challenge. |