Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
the horizon is leaning a bit to the left, however this is still a really nice shot. I like the lonliness of the tree..adds a lot to the neg. space idea. your focus and clarity are great, and the lighting was definately on your side. really nice job. good luck in the challenge. ~hbunch7187~
Post actions
Post actions
What was growing there earlier?
Post actions
Truly superior and a nice catch. Love the flow of the land. 10....hokie
Post actions
Very striking. This reminds me of the tree portrayed in the "Little House on the Prairie" opening credits. Composition and colors are very good.
Post actions
I might have been inclined to shoot this one in BW, as the dead plants are integral to the lonely image of the tree, and BW tends to emphasize that broken feeling.
Post actions
good use of negative space
Post actions
think I'd prefer to see the horizon line flat - even though it probably wasn't in reality
Post actions
Apologies for not leaving a proper comment. Please email me if you'd really like one. I’ve voted this image a 6. Kavey
Post actions
Nice negative space and great framing. It makes you feel like the field goes on forever.
Post actions
Great shot. I like how you did negative space in the foreground and the had the tree and nice area in the back. Good shot. 9
Post actions
Very nice composition. I like this better than some others because your "negative space" isn't all uniform (i.e.: one solid color) which a lot of people seemed to do this week. It probably would have worked equally as well if you shifted prspective and filled most of the frame with the sky instead of the field.
Post actions
Post actions
Wonderful colors and contrast. karmat
Post actions
A super photo. Great capture on your part.
Post actions
I really like this. The composition is just beautiful and an excellent entry for this challenge. My only real problem with it is the bright sunlight. I think you might have tried a diffrent time of day. The focus is also a tad soft maybe, but this is a hard focusing situation. 9 ~indigo997
Post actions
Great shot. The question immediately comes to mind, "What the hell happened?!?"
Post actions
I like this photo but the lighting is a little harsh for my taste. I would love to see this same photo just before sunset or sunrise. rcrawford 6
Post actions
very nice. "Fun" to look at.
Post actions
Perfect! This tree will not be the same with all that dry grass around.
Post actions
Very good. You have delivered your statement.
Post actions
Very good. Maybe a bit too much sharpening/over exposure. Love the composition. Good luck. Score 7 Justine
Post actions
interesting juxtaposition of color and life 8 sgtpepper6344
Post actions
Very nice depth of field on this one. Focus and lighting look good. 8
Post actions
hmmmm I think b/w would pop this photo out more....however not a point issue:)
Post actions
Composition: I would have cropped the forground out and just had the tree and sky 4
Post actions
Visually, more appealing than Noel and / or Liam. I think a more equal balance of earth and sky would improve this photo. Nevertheless, a decent shot.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
