Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background very good,
Technical: Focus, Exposure: too overexposed which changing to sepia hasn't really helped
Appeal: A pity about the exposure as this would have been a really good stree shot
Total Averaged Rating 6.
I understand what you're trying to do here, but I had a very hard time finding the subject when I initially looked at the picture. Perhaps you can make it more obvious because to me, there are several people in the picture that can "stand alone".
I am very curious about the sillhouette (sp?), but needs to be more prominent. I enjoy that he doesn't belong, but I have to look too hard to find him, and see any detail
I find this photo hard to come to terms with as there is no real focus. When searching the photo, however, I find many things of interest so perhaps it is an interesting scene made less interesting by an over-abundance of interestingness. I think that's pretty interesting so I'm going to give it a 6.