I sharpened this alot with several runs through USM at differen radiuses and then I gave the picture a very strong blue tint. Then I used the saturation tool set to red and brought up the saturation of the red which was the only color besides blue left and then set it to blue and desaturated it quite a bit and got this effect. I have no idea how this will score....
Statistics
Place: 23 out of 110 Avg (all users): 6.0538 Avg (commenters): 6.6667 Avg (participants): 5.5676 Avg (non-participants): 6.1281 Views since voting: 1632 Views during voting: 451 Votes: 279 Comments: 17 Favorites: 0
I like it except for one thing...I wish the silouette din't have detail in the center of the head, it destracts from the image. Overall nice photo though.
You've done a nice job of processing this image and setting it up. The backlighting adds to it as well. One minor glitch...the dates on the headstone take away from the reality of the scene you've arranged.
My eye is begging for detail in the model that just ain't there. Just the tiniest amount of fill lighting would have helped this a lot. The red flower is a bit distracting and IMHO not necessary. It just doesn't add to the emotional impact of the shot.
TC
While this does convey emotion and the photo is well taken, it lacks originality. I'd suggest spending more time exploring different ways to convey a meaning.
can you do this with basic editing? Im guessing if you remove all the color except red from the whole picture and the only red are the flower and flag? Interesting, might be better with some more detail in the figure.
I like the lighting here. I'm not sure about the selective desat on the rose, as I think it takes away from the subject, but I do like the very slight desat on the flag.
I like the highlights in the hair. I think a partial desaturation would have worked a little better but that is my personal preference, or complete B&W, but I do understand what you were trying to accomplish. Usually I don't like frames but this one suits the photo.