Author Thread
Post actions
I just came across this picture and I had to tell you I think it's wonderful. What an amazing idea and beautiful lighting.
Post actions
I would have to say that what makes this picture so great is it's simplicity. Sometimes people OVER think their ideas, but this one comes out simple but just nails the challenge. I should've been thinking origami, since I live in Japan...but alas, I didn't. I have however tried to duplicate the shot with little success. I need to work on my lighting. You have it down pat!! Love it!!
Post actions
This is Amazing !! BRILLIANT!
Post actions
You're so clever. It's a pleasure to have you around.
Post actions
This was my personal pick for blue ribbon. Very nice indeed. So simple to make and print something like that in photoshop yet I've never seen anyone do that before. It's these kinds of things that make excellent photos--simple, original ideas. Your set-up, lighting, focus, exposure, all that stuff is all nice, but the idea itself is what won. I love this stuff and I love seeing images like this win. Congrats =] (Nice message, too. Honour killings should be condemned by all levels of government in those nations, not just discouraged.)
Post actions
congrats!!!
Post actions
If ever there was a shot that should have been above 8, this is it. It is thoroughly enjoyable to see your work. Your ideas are wonderful, and the way you make them real is truly fascinating.
Post actions
Great photo. What a smart idea with the photocopying the paper! never would have thought of somethinglike that.
Post actions
Congrats on the blue. My favorite in this challenge.(10)
Message edited by author 2007-08-02 22:58:49.
Post actions
The funny thing about you moving into the "blue" position is thatI couldn't believe that it wasn't the blue to begin with. This is another amazing idea and I think this sorta creative thought deserves high praise as it has here. well done.
Post actions
Well, shame that the other one was DQ'd but, in my opinion, this one shows much more effort and imagination! I absolutly love your mind, Jorge! Great work! "A WELL DESERVED BLUE!!!!!"
Post actions
Many congratulations Jorge!
Post actions
Jorge, just wanted to say congratulations on this one - I think it deserved the blue hands-down for an incredibly creative and well-executed idea.
Post actions
Excellent idea and very well executed!
Post actions
great work, simple and effective ... congratz !!!
Post actions
This is such a great idea. Congrats on a wonderful photo and ribbon.
Post actions
Beautiful work my friend. Congrats on another outstanding shot and idea.
Post actions
what a great concept! Congrats on another ribbon!
Post actions
Love it. Great idea, fantastic capture
Post actions
Minhas as palavras do gil...
Post actions
Parabéns, novamente. Mais um trabalho de referência.
Post actions
Creative idea, perfectly presented. Great stuff, Ribbonhog! ;-)
Post actions
Your are a CHAMPION, and this is just TOPS again.
CONGRATULATIONS dear friend.
Post actions
Post actions
Very creative photo...congratulations on winning the red ribbon!
Post actions
Terrific again haven't bored to impress us?
Post actions
very cool and very brave straight after paper challenge.
Post actions
Congrats Jorge. So you used a long "snot" for this one? How gross.
Post actions
Beautifully executed and presented...
Post actions
Congratulations on the red ribbon Jorge, this is a stunning image that deserved it's high score.
Post actions
Great work again, Jorge, congrats on your ribbon and sorry for confusing you with Shannon :)
Post actions
yikes this is just awesome
Post actions
Imaginative and well-executed as always!
Post actions
Post actions
congrats on the red, you are awesome :)
Post actions
Very creative guy, congrats to you!!
Post actions
had to be yours. Awesome!
Post actions
It is inspiring to see your creativity. Well done!
Post actions
Post actions
What a great image - very creative and very deserving. Well done I really like it.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
This is a very creative shot, amazing!
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Excellent job. Can't wait to see how you did this in basic editing.
Post actions
This is such a creative idea for a photo and you did a great job with the setup. Very nicely done!
Post actions
Good idea, i love this picture
Post actions
A fantastic idea, very clever. Well lit & composed. Top marks.
Post actions
Not sure how this was done but very good idea and exceptionally well executed and lit - 1st or 2nd in my view
Post actions
Idea Left over from the paper challenge lol. Great shot very cool.
Post actions
this would have been a great entry for "paper"!
Post actions
Post actions
cool idea...this should do well
Post actions
Post actions
i like the way you made the music look like water...cool idea! 9
Post actions
wow. that is incredible cool on so many levels
Post actions
Post actions
Marvelous idea and execution. To take that conceptual leap from presenting a paper swan on "water" of any sort, to a sea of musical notes that illustrates the word play with swan on a lake/Swan Lake is admirable. Edges of the swan against the black look slightly jaggy on my monitor - don't know if it's down to lighting or sharpening. Nevertheless this shot rates a 10 from me.
Post actions
I like this and it would have been an excellent entry for the Paper challenge as well!
Post actions
While technically a "Still Life", your composition suggests movement, which I think is counter to the challenge. Neat shot, though.
Post actions
Man, this would have slayed the field in the Paper challenge. My pick for the winner here too! Bravo!
Post actions
Outstanding!! Well thought out and setup. Sharpness is perfect, depth of field is right on the money!! (8)
Post actions
Great picture! I really like how you skewed the music notes - awesome.
Post actions
Wow! At last, a really interesting and creative entry! Well done!
Post actions
Pretty cool! Took me a second. Nice.
Post actions
Very creative & very well done
Post actions
Very creative and well done
Post actions
Shannon? Exceptionally creative shot!
Post actions
Very creative with the sheet music!
Post actions
love it :)...this would have done well in the 'paper' challenge
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
OOHH!!! how unexpected and creative!! this is simply lovely, this would have been great for the paper challenge as well. great shot
Post actions
cool! Very nice visual and creativity!....8
Post actions
Nice crisp capture and i like the shadows here- wud have done better in Paper challenge i guess
Post actions
Cool - love the ripple effect on the sheet music - Very nice!
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Very good idea. simple and efficient.
Post actions
Post actions
wonderful idea. great execution
Post actions
Swan Lake
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
