This was a simple shot taken while exploring an abandoned facility; this is my first submission, so I went with the basics for post processing. I did some basic leveling to bring out colors and add contrast, and a slight multiply on any well lit areas for a bit of a bloom.
Statistics
Place: 90 out of 150 Avg (all users): 5.4439 Avg (commenters): 6.2105 Avg (participants): 5.0862 Avg (non-participants): 5.5942 Views since voting: 897 Views during voting: 393 Votes: 196 Comments: 22 Favorites: 0
My first impression is that this seems a bit busy with no real subject that quickly grabs your attention. The main interest is definitely how you composed the shot to use the person's reflection. This is very novel and works wonderfully for this challenge.
The light and shadows play well with each other. Also, the soft focus gives this a surreal feel to it. Once you have looked at this for more than a few seconds, you begin to wonder what is the story going on here. What is this place? Why is this person here? This really brings some intrigue to this photo. The unfortunate thing about this, is that most voters only look at a photo for 2-5 seconds and you really need to look at this longer to truly enjoy it.
I see that this is only your second entry! Welcome to DPC!!! If you have any questions, feel free to PM me.
realy creative, neat take on the challenge - I like this! I know the clutter helps hide the waldo, but might be interesting and beautiful if you cropped out all concrete and rusty metal surrounding the blue and the green water. Just a thought. Another thing I also think is really awesome is the way the real waldo is cut in half by the crop, and the reflection is the same part that was off. :) Interesting photo.
Interesting take on the challenge, like the way that you have got waldos top half reflected but only his legs showing (now all I need to do is find his feet)
I had already set this as an 8, but it's getting bumped up. It's just wonderful. Great greens set against the dark water and the grey paths, wonderful use of the reflection to meet the challenge (the least of my concerns here, but a plus in your case), and good use of lines to drive the eye around the image. 9.
I love the tones of this image and stillness of the water and the out of focus bar, which I hope others don't dislike too much (many people have a tendency to have things that aren't in focus for no good reason).
I do like that part of him is on the top and the rest in reflection on the bottom...but I find the image really poor in quality overall...not the composition, just the blurriness and lack of sharpness overall...5