Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Love the vibrantcy of this photo as it shows so many different shades of the colour and the simplicity makes it a very eligant photograph.
Post actions
great photo, nicely done.
Post actions
Filling the frame is ok, but I think the image would have more impact if you backed off a bit more and/or had a little more contrast. The red of the bloom is overpowering.
Post actions
beautiful but a litlle too much and intensiv red
Post actions
I think it would have been better if the shot was a little smaller.
Post actions
The border takes away from the rose
Post actions
I really like the closeup rendition of the rose; it's perfectly lighted and very sharp. I think the frame seriously detracts from the photo, especially as it is inside the picture, rather than around it.
Post actions
Stop and smell them, yes! Frame them? NO. It's a strong image BEFORE that big-a frame. It doesn't need containing. You did it with the original image.
Post actions
a bit oversaturated... nice though.
Post actions
Post actions
Beautiful picture. May be just a little over saturated.
Post actions
This looks a lot like one of the soft focus winners. It would be nice to try and avoid repeating a picture so closely. slightly blurry
Post actions
Very nice, the border adds a lot to it but I'd have made the red match the red in the photo better. I like the soft focus.
Post actions
Nice close-up; I like the light on the edges of some of the petals
Post actions
Nice, but rather unoriginsl.
Post actions
the rose is beautiful.....very nice composition and color.....I just wish it were sharper in focus, but that is just my opinion! I am still giving it a good score!
Post actions
too unsharp for a macro shot. Also slightly over saturated with red. Some water drops would be a good inclusion next time.
Post actions
Very pretty- beeee-utiful!
Post actions
Very nice composition. Maybe a bit too saturated.
Post actions
creative way to sneak in a floral shot
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
