I like the grain you've included, but I find the composition and placement of the structures to be odd. I think you could have also cropped about an inch and a half off the top as the sky has no interesting detail. Would have also liked to have seen this in landscape format.
Your photo appears fairly pixelated on my monitor, though not unappealing so. Kind of gives the shot a grainy "old" feel that is in keeping with the subject. Choice of black and white is perfect for this scene.
Beautiful use of black and white and an old fashioned grainy looking style. I know you'll get a lot of comments about cropping off some of the top, but I think I really like it... gives it that distant feeling that puts it kind of in the past, I like the free space.
The extra noise works well with this shot, gives a classic historic feel, black and white is nice also. Only fault I would mention is that I feel that the border may be a little to thick, otherwise very nicely done. 8
Beautiful composition, I love the noise introduced in this photo. The tilt at the bottom doesn't really bother me. I would have preferred the subjects to be bigger and crop the top which no detail can be seen anyway.
This is a wonderful shot. I think there might be a bit too much empty space at the top, but the composition is perfect otherwise. There are not many photos that I enjoy that are noisy like this, but for this shot it is just perfect!