Author Thread
Post actions
Where was it taken? Could be almost any rural scene from Central California.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I like the effect you used on this. Good crop, lighting, colors and meets challenge well. a little bit of wow for me but not a WOW. 8
Post actions
Post actions
Think it's just too grainy. Nice photo anyway.
Post actions
I really like your processing, great grain! I'm picturing this photo without the grain (texture in the road and sky) and it isn't nearly as effective as what you have presented. I hope voters reward you for this beautiful processing. 9
Post actions
The noise here is really too much. More like a stucco painting than a photo.
Post actions
I love the deep rich colors and the grain. The grain my be just a tad much but it's still very nice. 7
Post actions
Post actions
Very nice processing. Good luck
Post actions
if that is not noise... i personally dont like the effect..
Post actions
I didn't like the graininess to begin with, but it's growing on me. It definitely meets the challenge, and the guy walking towards the vanishing point adds to it.
Post actions
Post actions
Interesting photo. Almost more of a pointalism (sp?) painting than a photo.
Post actions
Post actions
I would have scored this higher without the grain.
Post actions
a little bit too grainy, otherwise a nice shot
Post actions
eheheh event horizon..... good the composition and the light nice colours. a good photo. I don't know if the grain works perhaps was better the gaussian blur. 8
Post actions
I think your processing as turned a good photograph into a bad one here.
Post actions
Very nice! I like the grain.
Post actions
I like it but I'm not sure if the processing is consistent with basic editing rules.
Post actions
The noise thing doesn't work for me - I like grain but this is too much. The colors are really nice.
Post actions
the stippling seems a bit much
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
