Greetings from the Critique Club -
I will first say that I voted this high in the challenge. I really liked it during voting and I still like it now.
The flip works well. The colors are nice and the ripples just look cool. And the duck. The duck ROCKS!
This is a very artistic type image which is harder to give a critical comment too. Almost abstract you have a piece here that I can't say a better focus or cloning something out would have improved it. It is what it is.
I found it to be a pleasing and interesting image that was well captured. 5.7 is nothing to sneeze at, but a lack of real WOW power is probably what kept you from scoring higher. Nothing technically wrong with your image IMO, just maybe not everyones cup of tea. It is mine though. I enjoyed it.
Good luck in future entries!
Tim |