CRITIQUE CLUB COMMENT
First off I'd like to say that the coloring and the composition are both very nice. You also made good use of shallow depth of field so technically I don't find anything wrong with you photograph with the possible exception of it beeing perhaps a tad too dark. Looking at your voting curve I see a boat load of the voters gave you a 5...right dead down the middle. In fact the entire curve is evenly dispersed around 5. My guess is that voters didn't see anything in the photo that really moved them too much either way. The photo fails to say anything or evoke an emotion. It is simply a photograph of something in a kitchen and while technically that's what the challenge was, voters might have been expecting something more creative. To get a few more points out of the score you might want to look for something that makes the photo truly unique. Either a piece of kitchenware that most people don't have anything like it or do something creative with an everyday object. Again, you have a solid photograph in the technicals department though. Might be a good shot for a micro stock agency. Keep up the good work. |