Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
I like the perspective of the photo, but not the red post processing.
Post actions
To tell you the truth the odd red coloring that just applies to the sky and dead tree (why did you just color part of the green trees red) is not at all to my taste and I can´t figure why you chose to only apply it in such a sloppy manner to just a part of the photo.
Post actions
Something's off with the processing. 2
Post actions
Albeit I am on the road and working from a laptop, I do believe you may have over saturated the colours on this one as the shoreline, the sky and most trees have a reddish hue to them. A very nice image, but your post processing my hurt you. Good luck.
Post actions
Post actions
This is great except for the weird colours.
Post actions
for my eye, it looks like too much editing. but that's just my preference many people would disagree with me
Post actions
Neat effect. Doesn't do it for me though. Maybe the water is too normal for the funky trees?
Post actions
is the pink sky for real or doctored up?
Post actions
WHAT!! This is a photography contest.
Post actions
Too much pink on the sky IMHO.
Post actions
The red tree trunks and ground look very unnatural. Otherwise very nice
Post actions
I don't really care for the color cast.
Post actions
Beautiful Hues - very well used colors to give a pleasant effect.
Post actions
This picture would have been a lot better if it weren't for that weird red haze.
Post actions
the colors in the editing do not work for me. the sky is too pink, the water too blue.. nice image just overedited.
Post actions
Post actions
I don't know about the colors here, don't know what you were trying to do
Post actions
Interesting concept but I don't see that the pink filter adds anything but rather detracts, IMHO.
Post actions
I'm confused by the magenta all over the place. It looks like a magenta dust was sprinkled over the trees.
Post actions
Post actions
I would have scored this higher if not for the harsh contrast between where the sky and land meet the water.
Post actions
The scene itself is nicely composed, but the unnatural colors don't work for me.
Post actions
Despite the overreliance on post processing here this is a striking image with strong exposure and well focused.
Post actions
Really cool shot after ...hmmmm..... four beers. I like it!
Post actions
Colors don't do anything for me...
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
