Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Nice use of B&W, bad use of composition. The image is too much in the center.
Post actions
I think I would like this even better if the man was positioned off-center to the right.
Post actions
A less centered composition would have been a lot better IMO.
Post actions
I like the grain/noise. I think an off-set rather then centered might have been better for me.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
on one hand I really like this shot because it breaks some of the rules ... very grainy, rule of thirds, exposure ... but that also hurts this shot a bit ... I'd like to see more details in the ground and person ... 6
Post actions
Very grainy and I'm not sure it really works with this shot. I like the simplicity of it, but would prefer and off centre composition.
Post actions
good shot but could be not so grainy
Post actions
I love this one. I'm guessing the noise was intentional. It added texture
Post actions
I think I would like this more if the man were on the right side of the image (in the 1/3 position).
Post actions
Post actions
I don't like the composition in the middle. good the silhouette and I like the grain. 6
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
