Looks delish. I love how you can still see the milk on the cookie. Great job of taking a photo through glass. That can often be tricky, but looks like you've mastered it. No reflection, no glare! The clarity and angle are perfect. This photo screams childhood. Great job and good luck in the challenge.
this is just so cool in its simplicity. the lighting gives it an almost surreal look. unfortunately i have to mark off 5 points because you used a cracked cookie. hehe, just kidding! i love it. 9--amitchell
I like the dipping view, very nice (even though I don't dip) I like the milk on the cookie and having it touch the milk is a nice touch. Nice lighting, interesting framing, great color, plain background works for me with this shot. 9 Swash
I like the detail on the biscuit (if you're American, let's say cookie) but find that the detail of the milk and glass is lost against the white background. Perhaps this is intentional? 6, Kavey
looks very tasty. nice composition too, but i dont like the milk blending in with the background to the left of the cookie. if there was just a bit more definition there I think it would not be so jarring visually for me. (6) ~mcmurma
I really like this, its a good closeup of the cookie, I might've shot it with a bit darker background though. I also read once that in commercial pictures, of something like this, they actually use Elmers glue instead of milk, it looks like milk in the picture, doesn't look watery, and now get this, they say it looks more appietizing....lol I do like it though, good job. (7)
Superb - I really like the way you have captured the challenge; the shot is both childish and mouth watering, the composition is first class and photography is unfaultable - I think this is an easy 10.... Bet you got to consume the props after as well :)