It's a great picture technically. However, I think it looks a little busy which gives it an artificial, set up look. Perhaps a few less tools would have helped. Sorry to be negative…
Great photo, the lighting is nice, and although there are many items in the photo, it doesn't look cluttered, they are very nicely placed. The yellow pencil seems a bit out of place, but I think you did that just in case someone didn't think the carpenters pencil was enough to "meet the challenge". If this were my photo, I'd take the yellow one out (not needing it to "meet the challenge") retake the photo and hang it in your shop. It looks like it would have personal meaning to you, and is pretty cool to look at. It makes me wonder what you used to make with all this. Birdhouses comes to mind. Don't know why. Anyway, great photo and good luck in the challenge.
I love the older flat wooden pencil - it's colours and form blend well with the other subject matter. I find the yellow pencil a little out of place. I look forward to seeing your outtakes, if you are one who shares them, to see if you have other compositions and arrangements of the items. Kavey
Meets Challenge Theme:yes Technical :good dof Composition:too busy for my taste Creativity:fair Remarks:I'd try a few different arrangements...maybe you did, I just am not crazy about this arrangement. Grayce...aka...Gracious
How true! Mine was HGTV and decorating the house, and gardening.... I now have unfinished projects (curtains, blinds, etc) and weeds in the garden... (Hey! they're green though!). Unique and refreshing idea here. Incorporates the pencil without making it the main subject. Good work!