Author Thread
Post actions
Top 10 - great Birkir - congrats... Absolutely beautiful rose and picture.
Post actions
Post actions
One of the most beautiful shots of Rose I've ever seen! Congratulations with the top 10 Birkir, well deserved.
Post actions
A top 10 Birkir, thats so fantastic.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Beautiful detail and color. The water drops look suspended in air. Great clarity. 8
Post actions
One of the best red roses in this challenge.....A "10" from me.....
Post actions
Really nice photograph. There's a number of "red roses" in the challenge - but your red is as deep as the petals are sharp! And I love the water drops and overall composition! 10
Post actions
the highlights in the droplets are way too blown somehow :( Also they dont look as if they are on the flower at all, considering there are some which intersect an edge, did you put a transparent plane above the rose or something?
Post actions
The drops are on something transparent above the rose? That doesn't really look right...
Post actions
I liked this one, it wasn't like all the other roses.
Post actions
one click too sharp in my eyes... nice though
Post actions
Post actions
This is nice and crisp. Certainly 'Red'. :D Something about the water droplets is throwing me off on this. Maybe it's the pure white lighting? Makes it look a little unnatural and studio(ish), rather than warm lighting you'd get from natural sunlight. All JMO of course. Good luck in the challenge.
Post actions
always a good photo,but not very original
Post actions
Very beautiful. Are the drops on a plastic sheeting above the rose? Whatever it is - it looks good.
Post actions
nice picture - well centered and i like how it fills the entire photo. the dew drops are a nice touch and add dazzle
Post actions
8. Beautiful rose and unique from the other entries because the way the drops were applied.
Post actions
beautiful and the water drops are amazing
Post actions
Beatiful, but I don't care about the white border (not taking any points for that though)
Post actions
sharp picture! I like this one.
Post actions
I love the water droplets. Nice shot!
Post actions
Great picture. Finally a good red picture! 10!
Post actions
Post actions
Lots of roses, but I think this one is the best. Great job.
Post actions
this somehow looks fake - the droplets cannot possibly be on the roses petals. A bit too much of them, too.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Is the rose under a glass? Nice shot
Post actions
nice, I like the droplets effect
Post actions
didn't I see this rose in the challenge last week, and the week befor, and the week befor. -still nice shot
Post actions
Really beautiful. Love the light, the colour, the drops... lovely.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
