Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Interesting idea, but im not a big fan of the lighting.
Post actions
The idea is good, but the lighting is sort of strange and dark. Maybe next shoot froma different angle!
Post actions
Works for me! Would have liked more light on the subject.
Post actions
Good idea, but, yeah you knew a but was coming.... the image is on the small side which isn't helping you, and your light and dark contrasts are too extreme. The wine and the bottle are so dark and the lamp is so white and bright. It makes it hard to find a happy medium in the photo. Your concept is good and the staging is nice though. Keep trying and better luck next time.
Post actions
Good lighting, love the lipstick and GREAT LAMP!
Post actions
I like the concept, however, the image is very small and the light itself really takes away from the effect the rest of the image can have. I would love to see a more advanced edit on this image. Maybe masking out the light so it is not so bright, and adding a bit more brightness to the glass/bottle/cork/doelly.
Post actions
This comes down to the image size. It's hard to criticize much about this picture when it's so small and difficult to see. From what I can tell, the image is very nice and soft, and the colors are good. The light is a little distracting from the rest of the composition. The bright white pulls the eye away from the subject.
Post actions
Awesome lighting ...i like the hint with the lip stick
Post actions
Nice idea, but the lighting is really off. Perhaps you could have used a lower-wattage bulb?
Post actions
Post actions
I love it! Nice job Jo. Keep up the good work! We are proud of you!
Post actions
Could use some brightening in the bottom half of the photo and less in the top. The light is so bright that it's glaring. Not a good effect.
Post actions
apparently we have a lot of drunks on DPC. make sure to make that photo size 640 pixels on one side. that will raise your score right there. 4
Post actions
a bit small, the light is blowing out the rest of your image, nice idea though, I like the lipstick on the glass, nice touch.
Post actions
I like the light but the composition is a little off and the image too small.
Post actions
Post actions
This is cute - good colors, but very small.
Post actions
The lamp is a bit of a hot spot, the bottle and the wine glass definitely need more lighting on them, just so they can stand out a little more.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Why such a small shot????
Post actions
I would recommend using the allowed size! that's my medicine too...
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
