Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Did George let you borrow that?
Post actions
Awesome Man!!but what's the on ur finger?lol
Post actions
love the detail in this shot looks great i gave ya a 9
Post actions
I score this photo 10 out of 10. The imagery captures the title of the book in an authentic way; i.e., the ring is a symbol of fellowship as strong as a steel chain
Post actions
Very well composed. Great use of light, great clarity! 10
Post actions
Very good picture, I like the warm tones of the hand and gold against the black background. But after the competition you would want to remove that distracting piece of skin on the finger. 8
Post actions
Although this is a very good / well shot image, I feel it is to much of a copy of the origional. Technicaly I think it's great.
Post actions
Beautiful photo, nice warm color and composition!
Post actions
awesome picture, great match with the book title! 10
Post actions
Good job, like the colors and the DOF, very nice.
Post actions
Nice idea and composition, the only thing at it is a very small thing and I am totally nitpicking here is the hang nail on the middle finger, it makes me want to reach in with my nail clippers and clip it!!! LOL...but like I said that is a very small thing!! 8
Post actions
fantastic... Other then the hangnail on the middle finger. Nice light, and the fingernails are just like the hobbits.
Post actions
this feels very distorted to me
Post actions
Pretty!!! Fantastic lighting!
Post actions
Good job! But, you know, at least in FOTR the movie, when Frodo holds the ring (that looks like this picture), the ring doesn't have the chain on it yet :))
Post actions
this is more a picture of the content of the story than a picture of the title. very attractive though. the torn/broken fingernail is distracting.
Post actions
Your model, focus and lighting are outstanding. Good job. Top three!
Post actions
Great shot, but the ring is upside down. A bit more DOP would have helped, too.
Post actions
This hand is from Froddo Bolsist? I guess this photo will be taken.
Post actions
Hey almost like mine! But much better! Very cool perspective, great lightning!
Post actions
hangnail is a little distracting, but otherwise a good picture - 7
Post actions
nice lighting, and a great shot all around. a little obviously inspired by the movie, and the hangnail on your middle finger is a little distracting.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
