this would be a pretty bland picture if it weren't for the weirdness of the texture; perhaps it is oversharpened or something but it fits in with the odd look on the guy's face
This shot is creepy- the lack of saturation, focus, and contrast is intoxicating, but the jeans don't do it for me. brings me back to 21st century reality.
Has an unsharp, noncontinuous tone look to it. Not sure if you did this intentionally to give it a painterly feel; the wall looks good but overall it doesn't look as good as if it were sharp and clear.
I hate his pose, He looks scared of the piano. You have a hot spot on his forehead, and what is with the rest of the photo... is it compression or a artistic filter? I really like the eye contact, but there are certainly areas for improvement.