Author Thread
Post actions
Great shot, congrat's on your blue.
Post actions
Congratulations Jim. A truly worthy blue ribbon winner and a very memorable image. :)
Post actions
Congratulations on the blue -- well deserved for this wonderful photo.
Post actions
Post actions
Congrats on the blue! Missed the voting, but would have scored this VERY HIGH. Tonal range is amazing! It's a great photo!
Post actions
COngrats on the first blue! Nice shot!
Post actions
Wonderful shot, love it! Congrats.
Post actions
yohooo!! congats!! this is clever and beautiful, and very very "friendly". good to see it's a man who is this baker ;)
Post actions
Jim, this is AWESOME!!!! I too missed voting on this one in the challenge, but I assure you, you would have had another 10 had I gotten to it! 7.4!! Wow. . .and it deserves every bit of it! MEGA congratulations!!
Post actions
I didn't get to finish voting and missed this one - what a truly wonderful shot. Excellent composition, great subject, very warm and inviting and real. Thanks so much for sharing this! (And I'll bet the bread was good, too - nice bonus!)
Post actions
This is beautiful, Jim! Many congratulations.
Post actions
Congrats on the blue!! Very nicely done!!!
Post actions
Best of class, well done! Now when is the bread going to be done I'm hungry!
Post actions
congrats on the blue...I didn;t get to vote in this challenge so I missed this...well done
Post actions
Very well deserved ribbon, congrats. This is so real life!
Post actions
Well done. On eof my top picks of the challenge. COngrats!
Post actions
Oh well done: I really loved this image. So pleased it did well. It has the warmth and character that I love so much (not to mention it's ALSO in black and white - which makes me go weak in the knees at the best of times!).Message edited by author 2007-02-10 14:32:37.
Post actions
A beautiful image. Congratulation on your excellent score.
Post actions
Wow! Excellent image! Congrats!
Post actions
Congrats! I gave you a ten...well deserved!
Post actions
Congratulations. This was the only 10 I gave out for this challenge. Very well deserved.
Post actions
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Very appealing - more texture or sharper focus would have brought more to the 'party'. Perhaps more contrast or maybe more implied movement would have brought drama to help me personally like it even more. << 7 >>
Post actions
Ahhhh - love it - lighting is wonderful - Excellent!
Post actions
a bit too much softness in the hand on the left but b&w sets a great mood and the setting tells a great story -- one of my ribbon picks
Post actions
Great detail and composition, and creative use of the challenge.
Post actions
I love the dramatic feel to this image. The textures and contrast make it very interesting and beautiful. Great image!
Post actions
Post actions
I really love this photo, you can almost feel the dough in your hands
Post actions
Post actions
very good image. I like the black and white and the black area on the right side is fine. 9
Post actions
My personal favorite - well gone!
Post actions
My favorite in the challenge..a 10...clear, crisp and very interesting..I love the black and white.
Post actions
Post actions
Lovely. Interesting but unexpected subject matter. Great DOF and expsoure. 9
Post actions
A good gritty picture. I really like the b&w treatment. Bumping up to 8.
Post actions
Love this in Black and White. Nice subject choice,and a general wholesome, warm,, interesting picture that captures my attention.
Post actions
Great photo, this is one everyone "kneads" to see
Post actions
Post actions
I like this one, fits the challenge. 10
Post actions
Great stuff and non-boring unlike most of these in this challenge
Post actions
Very nice, perfect photo for this challenge. I wish I could see a bit more detail in the shirt though.
Post actions
This is a wonderful shot. Detail, textures, composition, and lighting all spot on.
Post actions
This is a fantastic photo, it's a great shot and looks brill in black and white.
Post actions
Post actions
The angle at which you shot this image gives the subject meaning and depth.
Post actions
The best part of this image is the use of all of the different textures. It really adds emphasis to the overall image.
Post actions
I love the way you've handled the lighting to isolate the hands and materials. Nicely done! Good luck in the challenge.
Post actions
perfect . . .i would only have done something with the left side of the frame.
Post actions
Excellent work! The details in the fingers and dough make the picture come alive
Post actions
wonderful in black& white. great shadows and focus. 9
Post actions
LOVE the way the hands seem to be an entity unto themselves! 10
Post actions
Absolutley wonderful. Great exp, lighting. Highlights are perfect as are the darks, exc. contrast! 10
The Baker
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
