I think that this is a good idea. the lighting is not quite what i would like to see in a shot like this perhaps if it was softer. i would have burned the spot in the bottom right corner.
The lighting, honestly, just looks like a flashlight is pointed at her (makes me think a little of "The Blair Witch Project"), and it's just not very flattering.
Interesting lighting, slightly flat, but works with the title. The pose is a bit boring, and works a bit against the title... unless the devious is you taking the picture without her knowing, but it's not quite right for that either. I think the shadows on the right side is a bit odd, but the falloff on the left side actually adds a bit of interest. I like the idea of the hair, but it just doesn't quite work right, cause it almost blends into the background.
This is one of those images where I think someone just wanted to get a naked picture in for the challenge. Not very creatively lit or even in a nice location or pose. With a beautiful model like that there are endless possibilities to make a tasteful interesting image that is worth sharing.