This is my favorite photo of the challenge. A coupel of reason here, first it is a great use of fill the frame. The lighting in the picture is terrific. The overal composition is superb, lots on lines, lots of well placed items. I like the color pallete on this one. Frankly this is probably the best use of "Expert Editing" that I have seen, one that isnt' over the top. Lovely image. Highly rated.
I can't imagine the work that went into this, so I wanted to acknowledge that it is a great shot, however usually this much PP doesn't do very well. But I think it is a great idea and shot, and wish you the best of luck in the challenge. 8.
a very good work. perhaps dnmc but a very good work. I rate it 7. but the work is for 10.
damn but the subject on the foreground is a horse!!!!!! at first time it seems a human face with an hat as the indians(what is the name that you use in USA for old apache,cheyennes,cherokee,navajos.....) hat. sorry, now isn't dnmc and I can rate it with 10 and I put this even in my favorite.
I would bet that the horse's owner would love this one. (I'm guessing that's the photographer too). very well done. Not sure if it's close enough to photographic intent for me, but I still like it very much.
A bit scary, not sure I would want it in my living room, but I like the composite, its theme, color and homogeneity in the concept. Nice work. 8. Lionel
i'd have preferred it with just the close up of the horse, but that's just my opinion ... you've done an amazing processing job .. excellent colours with such great tones and contrasts ... i personally didnt think it 'needed' the added horse .. but hey =8!