This is creative. I like how half of the space is opaque, the other half transparent. This type of photo tells a story, which very few photos do. Tecnically I think it could be a little stronger, but I think there is real artistry here.
I love the division of the composition in half. Am I the only one? I'll have to give you a 10, then. Honestly, you deserve it. the image has a lot of perspective, i.e. the front of the image is much closer than the back, but it looks utterly flat. this is an image I can keep coming back to and keep thinking about.
Detail on the bird is pretty good though a little too bright on my monitor; the white reflection in the water taking up half the frame feels like it's taking too much of the composition.
The bright reflection across the right hand side of the picture is distracting. It leaves you with half of the image being "blanked out". The clarity and colour of the pigeon ate lovely and I like the fact that it's walking in water. The ripples give the image movement and interest.