Very interesting. Definately creative. (Geesh, all those boxes of pencils!) I like how the one pencil is going opposite of the placement of the pencils on the box. Perhaps the one thing I would change would the the direction of the light - maybe. I can see some time and effort was put into this. 8 Ruthann
I like the idea and the background is clever but feels too busy for me. I don't know what to look at and where to focus. My eye can't just look around it and then settle, it's a bit too frantic for me. I do like the colours though. Kavey
I get the point, but I think with all the boxes, it's a little busy. I love the idea. Vocus and lighting are good. No disturbing shadows, and dealing with glass you kept the glare and reflection down nicely. It actually almost looks yummy. Almost. Great job and good luck with the challenge.