Author Thread
Post actions
Excellent. Great tone. Anyone else notice those stray white pixels?
Post actions
Post actions
Congratulations scab wonderful work!
Post actions
Congrats sugah britches ! ! ! !
Post actions
You fully deserve the ribbon here scabby (it's me...flumm)
Post actions
This was my vote for top honors but I guess a ribbon is a ribbon. Excellent Job!!!!!
Post actions
Good on ya Scabby, congrats.
Post actions
A nicely done still life, congrats on the ribbon!
Post actions
Scab, this is great. Congrats on the ribbon.
Post actions
You da man Scabby! I loved this! +fave!
Post actions
There you go again, Gary! Nice work!
Post actions
Congrats on the ribbon...very nice lighting and composition..good DOF...nice job!
Post actions
One of my favorites and the only ribbon shot I got a chance to vote on! Very nice job. Loved the lighting here. Congrats on your second ribbon!
Post actions
woohoo...congrats, scabby! one of my favorites!
Post actions
the lighting king...excellent shot scab
Post actions
Well deserved ribbon, love the light technique.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Cool! Awesome lightning! Beautiful shot!
Post actions
wonderful lighting, I love the simplicity of this shot, very nice. 10
Post actions
Interesting lighting - really makes the colours of the apples sing out and the black background amplifies that. Apples are sitting way too close to left and right edges of the frame for the composition to work for me... feels very very hemmed in. I think I'd add space left and right and also at top and lose some at bottom.
Post actions
There are a couple os spcks in the background, but this is a very good still life shot. The lighting is its best quality and sharpness good.
Post actions
If you're going to try to draw attention to the center apple by having it unripe (you WERE trying to draw attention to that apple, weren't you?), then the other apples shouldn't be partially unripe. If this is just a collection of unripe apples, then there's no reason that the center one should be so glaring. You are not in control of you photography or your meaning, and in order to win, you need to have that control.
Post actions
The best picture I've seen in this challenge. I'm a little distracted by the green spot on the apple in the foreground on the right side but it's not enough to take away from the score of 10.
Post actions
Beautiful lighting - I love how it fades to black at the bottom of the apples!
Post actions
Very efficient use of light and objects.. Excellent shot
Post actions
Post actions
Excellent lighting, a bit crowded but the arrangement and angle of the shot take care of that quite well. Great overall shot.....really like this a lot!
Post actions
One of the best. 10 from me.
Post actions
Wonderful lighting and original composition.
Post actions
Very nice color and contrast...well done.
Post actions
Very nice, I like the angle esp. 8
Post actions
If this isn't a ribbon winner, I don't know what is! Small glare on apple in front right is the only thing I don't like. Nice job. 9
Post actions
This is an absolutely gorgeous shot, very beautiful. The lighting, colors, and clarity are absolutely staggering! Good luck!
Post actions
Very interesting lighting!!! I like the overall effect! You get a distinct sense of depth. You do have a couple of hot spots though on the center and front right fruit. Nice shot!
Post actions
Macintosh are my favorites, besides that, the lighting, color and compostion is very good. Should finish in the top.
Post actions
great warm colors, good arrangement. If spot editing was allowed you should clone out the bright spot on the apple in front, on the right.
Post actions
Beautiful rich color with the most perfect lighting ! This is a stunning still life. I hope it becomes a print !
Post actions
they look too much like they're floating... the bottom needs a little more light
Post actions
I really like this one. Excellent lighting and composition.
Post actions
Strange title, gorgeous picture, great lighting, shame about the hotspots. 7
Post actions
The lighting has made this photo very striking indeed. Love it.
Post actions
Beautiful lovely lighting.....Very nice......really nice.
Macintosh
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
