Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Sorry mate, but I'm not buying it :) Let me explain a little why, the expression: It's not an expression I'd expect to see in war. The composition is great, but he just doesn't sell war to me, he sort of looks a little out of place, and not like he's scared or angry. Faces tell the stories, and this story isn't selling to me. I simply don't believe in it. The BW touch doesn't work either, because it's too flat. Most war photos bw have artifacts, and pushed up contrast. And this just seem to simple.
Post actions
Nice duotone. Maybe a bit more contrast? Either way, I like it.
Post actions
Post actions
very nicely done. the conversion really makes it timeless. great expression, as well.
Post actions
That looks a bit like one of GWB's expressions!! I like the angle on this. Good tonality.
Post actions
A bit too light for me, also needs more sharpness.
Post actions
great expression. amazing perspective. nicely done!~ 7
Post actions
nice vintage look , with more grain it would be even better !
Post actions
Very dramatic composition. I like that you have gotten down on the level and given us that view.
Post actions
vintage, I would put a little dirt on his face and arm. well done
Post actions
Did you feel like you were satnding in the wrong place?? Nice work and the toning gives it that WWII feel to it. Good luck!
Post actions
Post actions
Like the vintage look to this.
Post actions
I like the emotion you captured
Post actions
I love your perspective here and the editing really suits the subject. The only thing I find slightly distracting is whatever is sticking out above the soldiers helmet :o)
Post actions
Best: Tones, expression, subject matter
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
