Fantastic high key shot that should have scored better IMO. Not sure why but it seems like high key is often underrated on this site. It looks like your commenters had more sensible votes! : ) Congratulations on a new personal best!
Oh how I LOVE these high key photos! I don't understand the 5.8 because I think this is just GORGEOUS! It looks like one of those sophisticated magazine ad photos for perfume or make-up!
gorgeous models, love their expressions but too much bright white for my taste. i also love their positions and the one model on the left's hand position. i'd love to see this a little less bright. still, i have to give it a 7, it's really a gorgeous portrait. no, i'm giving it an 8.
The high key of this one definitely works. One small request: consider lightly burning the lips to give them just a bit more definition, and this one would be a 10 for me.
I like this hi-key image. If I were to offer a suggestion, it would be to burn the eyelash area a bit more to really bring out their eyes. This is beautiful as is though.
I suppose you wanted to do a high key, but it looks more like blown out highlights - which is not what high key is about. Shame though, because I think this could have been really good.