Author Thread
Post actions
You would think that if someone didn't know what it was they would google it instead of saying "I don't understand" and giving a low score. I really appreciated this as this is what took my grandmother's vision. Great job!
Post actions
I found this to be a very creative entry, and appreciate the message. I think the lighting could be stronger, but overall a provocative and interesting photo.
Post actions
A great creative interpretation. Don't let the score get you down.
Post actions
i think the problem was that a lot of people don't know what macular degeneration is, i did not vote but if i did i probably would have giving it a 9.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Would have had the hole in the middle more fuzzy (you can see the cutting) and the background more homogenic. Otherwise a good idea.
Post actions
Post actions
The circle is a little rough, which takes away from this a bit, but the idea behind it is absolutely brilliant for the occupation.
Post actions
Really nice skin detail in the neck. However, I know the grey dot is supposed to be there, but for me it just seems to ruin the image. Maybe a grumpy face drawn on it, or even eye holes or something.
Post actions
great idea, nice colors, good lighting. would have liked fuzzier edge on greyed circle, in post processing
Post actions
Yep, my mom's just had an Op for this, now I know what she was talking about.
Post actions
my mum had macular degeneration ...
Post actions
.Message edited by author 2010-01-24 01:21:43.
Post actions
Good luck! I have a very dear friend who has that, and I hope you find some answers soon! Thanks for what you do!
Post actions
i must not be too bright because i don't get this.
Post actions
Dont like the big gray blob....it takes away a lot from the picture.
Post actions
i'm not sure i understand
Post actions
okay...have no idea what this means and what "macular degeneration" is...but intriguing composition.
Post actions
Post actions
i like it... the periphery is rather crisp, though :-)
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
