I like the idea a lot, but the composition feels a little off. I think it might be stronger if the boots were closer and the beret in full view. Hope if this is a family member in Iraq he (or she) comes home soon!
This is a sad sort of photo... I wish that people wouldn't have to miss their family. I think technically the lighting / contrast could be improved as well as the color balance. I do like the composition - it's a bit unusual but I think it works as it seems the child is reaching upwards for a father figure that cannot be obtained. I also really love the message "sweet home" on the clothing as it fits very well with the theme of the photo.
The idea is outstanding. The execution however needs improvement. This photo is sort of washed in a yellow hue. The black boots should be black even if you intended the yellow hue for a mood affect. A little less crop at the top so that there were more of the hat showing might have helped too. Overall contrast and color are what drags this one down for me. Keep smiling though because no matter what the score on this photo and no matter what anyone else thinks Daddy will love it when he gets home or if you email it to him.
Mmm the yellow tinge is distracting, could be a little more in focus, might have had more impact had she been holding/looking at a picture of her father (or whoever those boots belong too). But i know how hard little kids can be to work with so ill give you a 5
Aw, man... what a touching moment, title & expressed feelings here. Very emotive & compelling in concept.
Technically, though, it's rubbish (IMHO). The flat lighting & way skewed white balance are a huge irritant to me as well as the "lazy angle" perspective. Makes me think that the scene was thrown together & suddenly it's sincerity goes out the window.